Editorial Summary
A catastrophe called Israel Author – Abbas Nasir
- 06/20/2025
- Posted by: cssplatformbytha.com
- Category: Dawn Editorial Summary

In a firestorm of bombs and bluster, Israel’s latest campaign against Iran is cloaked under the veil of nuclear disarmament but reeks of deeper, darker motives. The writer pulls back the curtain on Israel’s military aggression, suggesting that regime change and distraction from the blood-soaked tragedy in Gaza are the real endgames. With Western allies turning a blind eye and the US offering not just tacit approval but logistical cover, Tel Aviv appears emboldened. The so-called Gaza Riviera Plan, visualising beachside luxury at the expense of displaced Palestinians, paints a grotesque picture of imperial ambition dressed up as diplomacy. Meanwhile, former Israeli PM Ehud Barak candidly admits that even a full-blown US-Israeli air campaign could only delay Iran’s nuclear progress for a matter of months. It’s a chilling revelation, exposing the futility of endless strikes and highlighting the fact that many of Iran’s key facilities lie buried deep underground, beyond the reach of bombs.
As the fog of war thickens, questions multiply. Can Iran’s missile stockpile, reportedly 2,000 strong, hold out in a war of attrition? Will the defiant Islamic Republic lash out further, risking regional mayhem to halt its isolation? And most importantly, will the United States risk boots on Iranian soil to fulfill Israel’s ambitions, knowing well its past disasters in Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan? The article masterfully weaves geopolitical fact with the looming specter of catastrophe, reminding readers that this isn’t just another border skirmish, it’s a simmering pot that could scald the entire Middle East and beyond. With no clear off-ramp and global silence enabling the chaos, this war risks becoming a disaster wrapped in denial, sustained by firepower, and fuelled by arrogance.
Overview:
This article critically unpacks the Israel-Iran conflict and the unspoken ambitions behind Israel’s airstrikes. It examines how these attacks serve as both a military and psychological tactic aimed not just at delaying Iran’s nuclear ambitions but potentially toppling the regime. It also explores US complicity, Iran’s retaliatory capacity, and the strategic futility of escalating a war whose fallout could reverberate globally.
NOTES:
The article highlights Israel’s ongoing military campaign against Iran, presenting it as a smokescreen for broader strategic aims beyond mere nuclear non-proliferation. While the stated purpose is to halt Iran’s nuclear ambitions, the hidden agenda appears to be regime change, aligning Iran with other Middle Eastern nations that have normalized relations with Israel. The writer highlights how the Gaza crisis and ethnic cleansing of Palestinians are being overshadowed by a wider regional war, further enabled by Western and especially American backing. The so-called Gaza Riviera Plan, aimed at displacing Palestinians and converting Gaza into a resort zone, underscores the cruel long-term vision behind the current violence. Former Israeli PM Ehud Barak’s candid admission that the airstrikes will only delay Iran’s nuclear progress by weeks or months raises serious questions about the efficacy and real motive of such military aggression. He stresses that without US logistical and ground support, Israel’s reach is limited, and any hope for regime change in Iran remains a fantasy. The article questions how long Iran can withstand this pressure, given its missile arsenal and limited air defence capabilities, and whether it might eventually retaliate by targeting US regional assets. It also examines how the fallout could destabilize the entire region and shake the global economy, especially if the conflict escalates or draws in other powers. With historical comparisons to America’s failures in Vietnam and Afghanistan, the writer paints a sobering picture of yet another misadventure driven by hubris, misinformation, and brute force, all under the guise of global security.
Relevant CSS Syllabus Topics:
- International Relations: Middle Eastern conflicts, nuclear diplomacy, proxy warfare, US foreign policy
- Current Affairs: Israel-Iran conflict, regional instability, international diplomacy
- Pakistan Affairs: Regional implications of Middle Eastern wars for Pakistan’s foreign policy
- Strategic and Defence Studies: War doctrines, regime change tactics, deterrence theory, missile and air defence systems
- Essay: Themes of global injustice, media manipulation, ethical warfare, and humanitarian consequences of conflict
Notes for Beginners:
The article shows how powerful nations can use war as a smokescreen to hide other motives. Israel claims it’s hitting Iran to stop nuclear weapons, but the writer argues it’s also trying to change Iran’s government and distract from what’s happening in Gaza. For example instead of rescuing hostages, Israeli envoys have walked away from possible deals. Former PM Barak admits their bombs won’t destroy Iran’s nuclear sites they’re too deep. This shows that wars often continue even when they can’t win anything clearly. Israel is better armed, but Iran, despite being hit hard, is still fighting back. It’s like pushing a wall hoping it’ll fall, not realizing it’s made of steel. The US hasn’t joined the war directly, but it’s giving support behind the scenes. This reflects the politics of influence and power that often shape world events, especially in the Middle East.
Facts and Figures:
- Iran has around 2,000 ballistic missiles
- Israeli strikes aim at both nuclear and military targets
- Israel’s “Gaza Riviera Plan” proposes beach resorts after forced displacement
- Iran’s uranium stockpile reportedly includes 400kg enriched to 60%
- Former PM Ehud Barak believes even with US help, Iran’s program may only be delayed by months
- Key nuclear facilities are located hundreds of yards underground
To sum up, this article is not just a war commentary but it’s a searing indictment of militarism dressed as diplomacy. With a sharp eye on hypocrisy, unspoken agendas and brutal consequences, it warns that wars like these rarely achieve their stated aims. Instead they leave behind a trail of human misery, global instability, and moral erosion. As the guns roar and diplomats play their cards, the real casualty might be not just a country, but humanity’s collective conscience.
Difficult Words and Meanings:
- Tacit: Unspoken or implied; synonym: implicit; antonym: explicit
- Perfuctory: Carried out with minimum effort or reflection; synonym: superficial; antonym: thorough
- Genocide: Deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group; synonym: mass killing; antonym: preservation
- Attrition: Gradual reduction of strength through sustained attack; synonym: weakening; antonym: reinforcement
- Apatheid: Systematic segregation based on race or ethnicity; synonym: racial discrimination; antonym: equality
- Scuppered: Ruined or destroyed; synonym: sabotaged; antonym: rescued
- Embattled: Involved in or prepared for war; synonym: besieged; antonym: peaceful
- Manifestation: Clear display or demonstration of a quality or feeling; synonym: expression; antonym: concealment
Excellent 👌